Each year Norval and Union Presbyterian churches celebrated a date close to Thanksgiving with a Fowl Supper, or the equivalent of today’s chicken dinner at many churches. These evenings were not only great fundraisers for the church, but times of socialization. A program of entertainment would be put together for the benefit of attendees.

28nov14_GH Fowl supper
The autumn Fowl Supper at Union Presbyterian Church with LM Montgomery giving readings for the after-dinner program (“Mrs. E. McDonald, readings”). Dinner and the program was a modest 50 cents. Unfortunately, this was the evening that Maud slipped on the steps and fell: “A busy week ended in a minor calamity Friday evening when I went to the fowl supper at Union church. When I was coming down from the platform after my last reading my foot slipped on the narrow steps and down I crashed. I jarred my whole anatomy rather badly and sprained my left arm and wrist very badly. I have it bandaged up in a sling…” Rubio, Mary and Elizabeth Waterston, eds. The Selected Journals of LM Montgomery, Volume III: 1921-1299. Toronto: Oxford UP, 1992. Print. 382. The Georgetown Herald, November 14, 1928.

Since the 1930s we have celebrated Canadian Thanksgivings on the second Monday of October, a date close to the end of our field harvests. Before that, however, the date was not always specific.

According to “Get to know Thanksgiving” by Canadian Living Magazine, “From 1879 to 1920, Thanksgiving Day was celebrated annually in October or November, to celebrate ‘the blessings of an abundant harvest’. From 1921 to 1930, Thanksgiving was combined with Armistice Day (now Remembrance Day), which was observed on the Monday of the week of November 11.”

29nov6_GH fowl supper
Friday, November 1 was the fowl supper at Norval Presbyterian Church. Dinner was downstairs in the Sunday School Room, and performances were upstairs in the sanctuary. LM Montgomery did not perform this evening, having noted in her journal on November 5 that she had “not felt at all well these past two weeks,” suffering from indigestion, headaches, dizziness and more. A short time afterward she had all her teeth removed, in preparation for dentures. The Georgetown Herald, November 9, 1929. Rubio, Mary and Elizabeth Waterston, eds. The Selected Journals of LM Montgomery, Volume IV: 1929-1935. Toronto: Oxford UP, 1998. Print. p. 22.

Combining the two events for one holiday may have been useful, but it did not give much respect to veterans who had served in The Great War. Armistice Day had begun on the second Monday in November, 1919 in the British Empire. According to the Canadian War Museum, Canadian Parliament passed an Armistice Day bill for ceremonies to be held on the first Monday during the week of November 11 beginning in 1921, and it was combined with Thanksgiving for a double-billed holiday. So during the 1920s, Canadians probably gave more thought to the Thanksgiving portion of the holiday weekend than for Armistice Day. But in truth, it wasn’t that many years after the first world war, and the whole concept of “remembrance” as we may consider it today was very young. There was little public demonstration: veterans, families and friends would gather at local memorials (many communities were only beginning to erect cenotaphs in the 1920s) or perhaps in church, but the observance was modest.

The Canadian War Museum also notes that by 1928 prominent citizens – many of whom were veterans – voiced their request for a stronger recognition of Armistice Day and separate from Thanksgiving. In 1931 the federal government decided that Armistice, or Remembrance Day, would be held on November 11 (the 11th day of the 11th month at the 11th hour, as we know it). Remembrance Day would “emphasize the memory of fallen soldiers instead of the political and military events leading to victory in the First World War.”

Thanksgiving would be our thanks for an abundant harvest to tide us through the winter to come.

33_nov15GH fowl supper
The 1933 Fowl Supper at Norval Presbyterian Church held November 9, courtesy of the Women’s Association. LM Montgomery (“Mrs. E. McDonald”) was a participant in the program, and her husband Ewan Macdonald (“Rev. E. McDonald”) was the host. Perhaps tradition trumped the change of the Canadian Thanksgiving date, and the WA continued to hold their fundraising fowl supper in November. The Georgetown Herald, November 15, 1933.


“After the War: Remembrance Day.” Canada and the First World War: Canadian War Museum, Canadian Museum of History. n.d. Web. 1 Nov. 2014.

Tancock, Kat. “Get to Know Thanksgiving.” Canadian Living. Transcontinental Media G.P., 2014. Web. 1 Nov. 2014.

The Georgetown Herald (dates in articles shown).

Rubio, Mary and Elizabeth Waterston. The Selected Journals of L.M. Montgomery (Volumes III and IV). Toronto: Oxford UP. Print.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s